Tucked into a small shopping strip across from the “Super Kroger” on S. Main Street Centerville is a little known place, where you can have a heck of a Food Adventure. It is an unsung, unassuming little business that you may find to be a new favorite “go to.”
Centerville Pizza and BBQ has quietly been serving up pies and even winning national recognition at pizza competitions. In 2017, they beat competitors in Columbus to catapult them into the “Super Bowl” of pizza competitions called the International Pizza Competition in Las Vegas. Pizza Chefs from all over the USA were there, as were pizza tossers from Italy, France and Korea. They placed 3rd in the Midwest, making their name on the leaderboard!
They were also featured earlier in 2018 in the national pizza magazine, Pizza Today !
So how come so many Daytonians have yet to try this pizza place?
HERE’S THE SKINNY on CENTERVILLE PIZZA and BBQ:
— Owner Robert Benson opened the business in 2010.
— The specialize in Pizza, BBQ and Broasted Chicken.
— Homemade dough, homemade BBQ sauces and Specialty pizzas are the hallmarks as well
— They are taking orders for Thanksgiving Smoked Turkeys! Average turkeys are 20lbs, and the price is $60. Pickup 11am Thanksgiving Day! Call for details 438.0223
— Located at 9470 Dayton-Lebanon Pike, they are open for take out, have a couple tables for dine-in, and deliver to a limited area in Centerville.
— Hours of Operation:
Monday – Thurdsay: 11am – 10pm
Friday/Saturday: 11am – 11pm
— They have a full catering menu as well !
BENSON FAMILY TRADITIONS:
In rural Tennessee in the early 1940’s, “Grandpa Benny” owned Benson’s Grocery. Locals grabbed groceries, tobacco, fresh foods made from scratch and even moonshine. Grandpa became “Moonshine Benny” known for his made from scratch foodstuffs as well. Fast forward to his grandson, now in Dayton known as “Pizza Benny.” He opened, Centerville Pizza and BBQ on June 1st, 2010 with a philosophy of pizza dough made from scratch, the best toppings, homemade sauces and signature sides made from real family recipes!
But what are the best menu items at Centerville Pizza?
The Food Adventure Crew has been getting take out and delivery for the past 8 years, and have some research into the “must eats.” Without further delay, here they are ….
MUST EATS AT CENTERVILLE PIZZA and BBQ:
THE ZOMBIE PIZZA:
Ok , sit back and absorb this one. This is one of the best pizzas you will ever eat. Period. They hit it out of the park with this combination of flavors. The sauce is ranch instead of tomato sauce. Ingredients include fresh garlic, fresh spinach, provolone and mozzarella cheeses, and finished with pepperoni, bacon, fresh diced tomatoes and Parmesan cheese. TRUST US ! Life changing !!
THE BROASTED WHOLE WINGS WITH HOMEMADE BBQ SAUCE or HOT SAUCE ON THE SIDE:
Talk about amazing flavor, this is a winner chicken dinner for sure. Get the wings broasted and ask for cups of their sauces bbq, mild, medium and hot. Crispy, and delicious fried chicken with a taste you will love. DO NOT forget to get those homemade sauces on the side.
Huge serving of pulled pork, and don’t forget to ask Benny’s crew for extra BBQ sauce and drizzle that stuff on top until you can’t drizzle any more. Great as a sandwich or just a fork and the plate. Melts in your mouth goodness. The smoky flavor is great and the prices are right ! Most underrated BBQ in town TRUTH BE TOLD !
CORN BREAD WITH BUTTER ON THE SIDE:
When eating BBQ , you cannot leave out the cornbread here. It is baked to perfection and sold in brownie like bites wrapped in plastic. Ask for butter on the side and you get a cup of liquid butter for dipping. NO trip to Centerville BBQ is complete without it.
BABYBACK BBQ RIBS:
The full and half slabs of these baby backs are affordable and delicious. The sauce is smothered on the ribs, but we still ask for extra bbq sauce for dipping. The ribs are a terrific and have a bold taste. Again, one of the best BBQs we have had, that you never hear about.
Is your mouth watering yet? If so, it is time to make a trip to Centerville.
Please check out this pizza shop, and experience what the buzz is all about. You may even catch Pizza Benny himself making some fresh dough, or serving customers. You will love the sauces and the BBQ. The fact that they deliver great BBQ and Broasted Wings is rare.
For more photos feel free to scroll down the gallery.
Food Adventures is a local food blog. We write weekly feature articles on DaytonMostMetro .com .